Arson is one of the most serious property crimes that is prosecuted in Maryland. As a result, those who have been charged with this offense risk severe criminal penalties if they don’t present a strong legal defense.
If you are facing an arson charge, one key issue that could make or break your case involves whether prosecutors can prove that you acted with intent. Unlike accidents or negligent behavior, arson involves a deliberate act. Proving that intent is a consequential part of the prosecution’s burden.
Intent matters
In Maryland, arson is defined as the willful and malicious burning of a dwelling or structure. There are different degrees of arson, depending on what was burned and whether anyone was harmed. However, across all degrees, intent matters. Prosecutors must demonstrate that the accused deliberately set a fire or caused an explosion. Simply being near a fire or owning particular property is not enough to secure a conviction.
Intent means that the fire in question was not set by accident or the result of careless behavior. For example, if someone knocks over a candle and unintentionally causes a fire, that would not typically meet the legal definition of arson. However, if prosecutors can show that the person set the fire on purpose—perhaps using accelerants or tampering with fire alarms—then the case becomes much more serious.
To prove intent, prosecutors often rely on circumstantial evidence. An experienced criminal defense attorney may argue that there is no direct proof of intent or that the fire was accidental. Expert witnesses, such as independent fire investigators, may help to clarify the cause or origin of the fire at issue. The defense may also raise issues like mistaken identity or false accusations.
Because arson charges are so serious and fact-specific, if you are under investigation or have been charged with arson, it’s important to get legal guidance as soon as possible to understand your rights and options.